[XML4LIB] Other XML projects

H.M. Gladney hgladney at pacbell.net
Tue Mar 19 09:35:49 EST 2002

Ref: "I hope this helps."

Thank you for trying.  Howewer, your response (attached) doesn't really
help, because it focuses on stating the challenge (which "everyone" knows),
whereas my question was directed at what the SDSC project taught that was
new about solutions (i.e., "what was the answer", not "what was the


-----Original Message-----
From: Andrew Ashton [mailto:aa2181 at csc.albany.edu]
Sent: Tuesday, March 19, 2002 5:28 AM
To: H.M. Gladney
Cc: xml4lib at sunsite.berkeley.edu
Subject: Re: [XML4LIB] Other XML projects

on 3/18/02 11:05 AM, H.M. Gladney at hgladney at pacbell.net wrote:

> Can you tabulate what this project teaches that is not inherent in
> pre-existing commercial software?  [To avoid risk of entrapping you by
> "lurking", let me say that I was involved with IBM's Content Manager from
> before the time it was called IBM Digital Library.]
> I do, of course, understand that XML schema are being defined and that
> so is needed, but my question is directed not at software development, but
> rather at novel ideas and architecture.

Let me preface this by saying my association with the InterPARES Project was
as a graduate research assistant, not a primary researcher.  The following
are based on my understanding and are not the same answers you might hear
from the experts.

The SDSC products are being designed to facilite archival management and
preservation functions.  The objects they are dealing with are records, not
just digital information.  Records may have unique formal characteristics
and metadata requirements, and they often fulfill a specific legal or
organizational function.  As far as I know, software designed for long-term
support these special needs is not available on the market.

The preservation of electronic records is tricky because records are
context-dependent.  Since it is impractical to preserve access through the
original software tools (i.e., the original context), one solution is to
develop software-independent tools that maintain as much of the original
context as possible.  XML is one application of this solution, but there are
plenty of options being looked at by various research projects.

I hope this helps...

Andrew Ashton
aa2181 at csc.albany.edu

More information about the xml4lib mailing list